Crossing Biscay - A Weatherman's Perspective


This was published as an article in PBO in August 2002 with additional information. This version includes the use of GRIB products.


 Introduction  The Outside Route  Round the Coast

Other Routes  

Island Hops Weather Forecasts
HF radio and email Telephone Services  GMDSS  What to look out for  Other Hazards  Last Thoughts


Introduction - Why is Biscay so feared?

 
Yachts going to (or returning from) the Mediterranean have the choice of using the French river and canal system, water and air draft permitting, or crossing Biscay - feared by many yachtsmen due to its legendary reputation. To a large extent this is a result of ships, in the days of square riggers, being unable to make way to windward having been driven into the Bay by the prevailing westerlies. In addition, the Atlantic swell can build up rapidly near the coast and a number of ports can become dangerous to enter or even inaccessible.

Modern yachts, with their much more efficient rigs and their engines, should not have the same problems - particularly if they use weather forecasts carefully. Nevertheless, there have been several occasions in recent years of yachts getting into difficulties, sometimes with fatal consequences. From the accounts that I have read, I believe that most of these problems were avoidable and that few were entirely a result of bad luck or even bad forecasting.

While we were waiting to cross Biscay in May 2000, two yachts arrived at Audierne having been caught in winds up to at least Force 9. One had left Finisterre with no forecast "it was a nice day with a southerly wind". The other left la Coruña with only the BBC 24 hour shipping forecast. Both were disasters that nearly happened.

In bad weather, Biscay can be as unpleasant as any stretch of sea anywhere. But, if you want to get to warmer climes, as we did, and having a draft of 2 metres, then crossing it becomes a must. Having had several years sailing in and around Biscay, having talked to others and being a (now retired) weatherman, I will try to give some help to those wishing to follow in our wake but who may have been put off by its reputation.

 


The Traditional Route


 

The "traditional" route for sailing vessels is to depart the Channel, going west of Ushant and out to or a little further than 10º W. The object is either to pass all of Spain and Portugal en route for the Canaries, to round Cape St Vincent en route for the Mediterranean or to choose a landfall on the west coast of Iberia depending upon the conditions at the time.

There are several advantages to this tactic.

  • First, by keeping far out a yacht will not be prone to the effects of any steepening of the Atlantic swell in the Bay.

  •  
  • Secondly, there are often increases of wind around the Atlantic coasts of Spain, notably off the extreme NW tip, Cabo Bares, and off Cabo Finisterre. How often does the shipping forecast say "........locally gale 8 near Cape Finisterre"?  These effects can be avoided by being far enough out to sea. 

  • Thirdly, you can choose your time when to approach the coast whether this be la Coruña, or further south, if going to. the Mediterranean or the Canaries and en route to the trade winds for an Atlantic crossing.

Weather is the most important consideration for most sea or ocean passages and Biscay is no exception. Even to Bayona - the landfall for the YM Rally Portugal, passage times from South coast harbours are likely to be near or beyond the range of reasonably accurate weather prediction. The many improvements in meteorology over the past 30 years due to use of the most powerful computers have resulted in forecasts for 5 or 6 days being of sufficient quality to be produced operationally. However, forecasts, particularly beyond

3 days, can, and do, go seriously wrong from time to time. The prudent yachtsman has to take this uncertainty factor into account.

The best time of year for this crossing is June or July. But, even then, a skipper would be well advised to be prepared for gale force winds even though none was forecast at the time of departure. At the very least, gales are always possible near the Spanish coast in the Summer as the Spanish heat low deepens during the day, especially when the Azores high intensifies or moves a little to the east. During the rest of the year, winds of force 9, 10 or more would always be a possibility.

In any event, and whatever the time of year, if you choose this option you must study the weather forecasts carefully - more of this later. Only go when there seems to be a good weather slot for the next 5 or 6 days. If you feel the need for further advice, especially beyond the 5 days or regarding confidence levels, then discuss the prospects with the Met Office, using MetCall Direct. The £17 or so could be money well spent. There are similar services available from other sources, eg Météo Consult.

Returning to the UK, all the same considerations apply - no one wants to risk closing the SW of England in a force 9.

Clearly, this is not a venture to be undertaken lightly and many find the prospect daunting. .The ever present possibility of strong winds make this passage far from ideal for many family or lightly crewed cruising yachts. I suggest that it should not be undertaken unless both boat and crew are equipped, and prepared, to full blue water standards.


Round the Coast


 

For the less adventurous, there are several options. The extreme opposite of the direct passage would be to hop around the coast in short, day passages mainly 12 hours at most. If you want an excuse for taking such a course of action then there is much to be enjoyed on the north and west coasts of Spain and France, particularly the rightly renowned Spanish Rias. For anyone with the time to spare this is well worth considering. There are, of course, some problems.

First, there are a number of ports on the west coast of France and Northern Spain that are difficult or impossible to enter if there is a big swell running. There have been instances in recent year, and at least one fatality through skippers not appreciating the effects of a big swell on the entrances to Sables d'Olonne, St Gilles, Bourg nay and so on. Also some ports on the north coast of Spain.

 Approaching Royan from the north means using la Grande Passe to enter the Gironde. On a spring ebb with even a moderate Atlantic swell, this can be very

dangerous. Listen to CROSS (French Coastguard) VHF broadcasts - they give warnings when small vessels should not attempt an entry. If in doubt, speak to them on VHF, or by telephone, to clarify a message that you have not understood fully. They are always very pleased to help and would rather do so than have to mount a rescue exercise.. The Passe du Sud never seems as formidable.  Although the buoys are unlit; the St Nicholas lighthouse, one of the leading lights, has a good intense sector.

Entering the Bassin d'Arcachon, likewise, can be stressful, and dangerous at less than half tide. Telephone the Cap Ferret semaphore station (they speak reasonable English if your French is too basic) and they will give you a window of entry based on the latest forecast. I have checked before leaving Royan and, again, by VHF when about an hour away from the entrance. I found them very helpful.


Betwixt and Between


 

Between the two extremes of crossing direct and coast hopping, there are various options involving passages up to three days or so. Such passages should be possible for many husband and wife crews, even if they have only ventured across Channel before. Weather prediction is such that, with care, these passages can be taken with considerable confidence.

My own preferred tactic, going south, is to cross the Channel to Audierne or Camaret. Audierne has my vote since it is the closest port in France to both Gijon and la Coruña. It is also south of the Raz de Sein - one less factor to take into account before setting off. It is well worth going up the river where you find a small marina in the heart of a delightful Breton town with all necessities (patisseries, poissoneries, boucheries, légumeries, creperies) right around the 

harbour. I usually find some excuse to stay a little longer than I really need. The harbourmaster tries very hard (and succeeds) to help in any way possible. From Audierne, there are three options -
  • First, short passages down to any of the islands from Groix to d'Oléron and thence to Santander or Bilbao.
  •  
  • Secondly, direct to Gijon.
  •  
  • Thirdly,. direct to la Coruña.

After each it is then a case of coast hopping passages as lengthy as you feel necessary and desirable.


Island hopping


 

In the first case, going down the islands, departures to a Spanish port can be chosen to give a crossing time from Isle d'Oléron, Isle de Ré or Isle d'Yeu of 36 hours or less, well within the realm of sufficiently accurate prediction. Bilbao and Santander are easy entrances in most conditions. One problem is that, with any swell running, the next all weather port after Santander, going westwards, is Gijon. This can give a longish sail along the coast. In good weather there are, of course, other viable, and attractive, options such as Ribadesella.

To Gijon


 

Secondly, the crossing Audierne to Gijon is likely to be up to 48 hours or so, again well within the range of accurate prediction. Gijon is another easy port to enter in all but extreme conditions. From Gijon, passages around the coast present no serious problems and it is possible to visit all the Ria Altas before getting to .la Coruña. Ria Cedeira is particularly pleasant and well sheltered. The principal hazard is probably the rounding of Cabo Bares at the extreme NW of Spain. Winds can often be strong here but MRCC Gijon broadcasts sea area forecasts in English and inshore waters forecasts in Spanish (as at June 2000). Before rounding the cape it is worthwhile checking with the forecast and waiting for a good slot. Call them up on VHF, they will speak enough English to give you advice.

To la Coruña


 

Audierne direct to la Coruña may be up to or a little over three days. Although within the scope of reasonably accurate forecasts it pays, as ever, to listen to each and every forecast from all sources available before and during the passage. If there is any indication that the forecast is becoming more pessimistic in tone, then consider diverting to Gijon or one of the northern Rias such as Barquero or Vivero.

After la Coruña, it is a reasonably easy day sail to Caramiñas just north of Cabo Finisterre, or a longer one to Ria Muros south of the dreaded Cape. We have rounded Finisterre twice southwards, once under boomed out Genoa and once under Spinnaker. After our one northward rounding, we had to wait five days in Caramiñas for gales to abate. We saw a great deal of lace being made in this

fascinating little town and met some interesting people. Notable was Frederick, a 70 year old Frenchman, single-handed in a Moody 379. Designed by German Frers, only 6 were built. Bigouden Bleu was one of a handful of yachts at Lézardrieux to survive the 1987 storm - and he was not insured!

If wanting to cross to Gijon or la Coruña direct from South Coast ports, such as Dartmouth, Plymouth or Falmouth, then passage times will be a day or so longer. It makes sense to go through the Chenal du Four and, perhaps, the Raz so that, if the forecast takes a turn for the worse, a diversion to Camaret or Audierne becomes feasible.

Going northwards, all the same ideas apply and the same crossings can be used.


Which Weather Forecasts?


 

For passages of over a day, extended range forecasts are essential both for the immediate passage and planning ahead. Whilst still in the UK, 5 day forecasts are available from MarineCall in text form (about £2.50) and from MetFax in text and chart form (about £3.50). . If you are happy to work from  forecast synoptic charts alone then these can be found on the Internet at no cost, apart from connection and ISP charges. GRIB coded forecasts can be obtained free of charge from Saildocs, GMN and MailASail and there are other services, some on repayment also  available. These enable  forecasts of winds up to at least 5 days ahead to be received via email or by very efficient webpage downloads..

 


RadioFax, GRIB code and Radio Teleprinter


 

 Offenbach and Northwood broadcast forecasts of sea state 2 days ahead, twice a day. There are forecasts of isobars and fronts out to 4 days ahead once a day from Offenbach, the DWD (German Met Service) Central Office. More usefully, the Royal Navy (Northwood) broadcasts UK Met Office charts, twice a day, up to 5 days ahead with isobars and winds. The wind vectors (usually only shown for speeds >25 knots) show the wind direction along an arrow shaft with "feathers" indicating speed. One long feather = 10 kn, one short feather = 5 kn, a solid triangle = 50 kn.

Offenbach and Northwood broadcast forecasts of sea state 2 days ahead, twice a day.

GRIB coded data are displayed using viewers obtained free of charge. A MaxSea display is shown here.

A very useful service is on Radio Teleprinter from the DWD. Software that can be used with the SSB Radio Fax transmissions usually contains coding to deal with RTTY as well. The DWD give spot wind forecasts for up to 5 or 6 days ahead for several areas but, unfortunately, only two days ahead for the "Western European Sea" which includes a "route" across Biscay, round Iberia to Gibraltar and down to the Canary Isles. Rather curiously, they do include a Biscay grid point right near the end of the Mediterranean 6 day forecast. They include the English Channel at the end of the 5 day forecast for the North Sea. Although not necessarily representative of an area, these do give good guidance as to the likelihood of severe weather.

The examples were received on the morning of Thursday, 31 May, 2001. On the basis of this information, I would not be planning to start a crossing likely to go beyond noon of Tuesday, I would, of course, be watching the next broadcast with care.

 
ENGLISH-CH.-W (49.6N 4.1W) SST: 13 C 

FR 01. 00Z: NW-N 4-5 / 1.5 M // 
FR 01. 12Z: W 3 / 1 M // 
SA 02. 00Z: NW 4-5 / 1 M // 
SA 02. 12Z: NW 5 / 1.5 M // 
SU 03. 00Z: N 4 / 1 M // 
SU 03. 12Z: NW-N 0-2 / 1 M // 
MO 04. 00Z: N 0-2 / 0.5 M // 
MO 04. 12Z: S 0-2 / 0.5 M // 
TU 05. 00Z: E-SE 3-4 / 0.5 M // 
TU 05. 12Z: SW-W 4 / 0.5 M // 

BAY OF BISCAY (46.4N 5.7W) SST: 16 C 

FR 01. 12Z: NE 3-4 / 1 M // 
SA 02. 00Z: NW-N 4 / 1 M // 
SA 02 12Z: NW 4 / 1 M // 
SU 03. 00Z: N 4 / 1 M // 
SU 03. 12Z: E 4 / 1.5 M // 
MO 04. 00Z: E 4-5 / 0.5 M // 
MO 04. 12Z: E-SE 5 / 1.5 M // 
TU 05. 00Z: SW 4-5 / 195 M // 
TU 05. 12Z: W 5-6 / 6-7 2 M // 
WE 06. 00Z: SW-W 4-5 / 1.5 M // 


Telephone services


 

If abroad, then Météo France or the private firm Météo Consult have similar services to MarineCall and MetFax at broadly similar prices. Alternatively, subscribe to MarineCall Club to be able to use their service from an overseas PTT or use a BT charge card which allows access to the BT system from any PTT and hence to MarineCall or MetFax. (remember that BT Premium rated services are not otherwise available through other PTTs). Another option is to use a UK mobile phone - but ensure that you have made the necessary arrangements before leaving the UK - otherwise you will find the numbers barred.

GMDSS


 

While on passage NAVTEX and/or INMARSAT-C are extremely useful to get twice a day 24 hour forecasts and brief outlooks. The BBC Radio 4 shipping forecast with its 6-hourly updates is a must. MRCC VHF are valuable while near the coast but will not be received once over about 30 miles out to sea. For a comprehensive list of available services go to my  Essential Sites,  GMDSS and other pages listed on  my Home page   where there are  Internet links, RadioFax, Radio teleprinter, VHF and MF schedules, notes on  GRIB services etc .

What to look for


 

Start a few days before you want to depart and study the forecasts on an ongoing basis. Compare the forecasts produced on one day with those on the next day and look for inconsistencies or trends. Inconsistency implies uncertainty in the outcome. A trend such as an acceleration of the collapse of a high suggests that the forecast is struggling to keep apace of changes in the current general pattern. Both situations require caution.  Use the ideas given in a lecture day to the HROA.

Having decided to go, then keep monitoring the forecast using the Radio 4 BBC LW Shipping forecast, INMARSAT-C, or NAVTEX from CROSS Corsen and la Coruña. Take each and every forecast, make notes of voice broadcasts - do not trust to memory. Remember that the French and Spanish NAVTEX forecasts use three areas to cover Biscay. They should be more specific than the UK single Biscay area.

A major strength of the BBC LW broadcast is that each forecast uses all the latest data including output from the 6-hourly runs of the Met Office operational numerical weather prediction model. Even fairly small changes from what was previously expected should be watched with care. The changes may not affect your area. But, they just might. Be that little more alert. While in range listen to the Inshore Waters broadcasts by the CROSS stations. If you have SSB radio then take the Radio Fax or the RTTY broadcasts.

All the time be on the lookout for any changes in emphasis or suggestion of uncertainty in the forecast. If you are unsure then consider diverting - say, to Gijon if your destination was la Coruña, or to Santander if Gijon had been in your sights.


Other Hazards


 

The firing range off the coast south of the Gironde can be a problem but the Capitaineries at Royan and Arcachon, or Cap Ferret semaphore, will advise or give you a telephone number to call. A night time passage down the coast to or from Arcachon is always (I think) possible as are weekend day time passages. The advice of a French skipper for day time passages was "always check - even in August when the range is advertised to be closed!"

God drew this bit of coast line on a Mercator's projection chart with a ruler and, visually, it is just as interesting. We prefer to do it by night in two bites to/from Arcachon. At worst, the weather and the firing range activity can mean waiting for a few days before proceeding. This is hardly a penalty as there is much to see and do. For example, Rochefort, up the Charente is well worth a few days of anyone's time.

 On all Biscay crossings, ships and fishing boats are an ever present problem. I have never done the direct "outside" passage but would have expected ships transiting between the Ushant and Finisterre TSS to be a constant worry. We had few ships on the routes to Bilbao, Santander, Gijon or la Coruña. We have only had substantial numbers of fishing boats at the northern end of crossings Santander to or from the French Islands.

If departing or arriving at Ile d'Yeu, then be sure to give the Rochebonne Plateau a wide berth. It creates a rough sea for some considerable distance around it.


And finally..................


 

Remember the old adage about there being old sailors and bold sailors but few old, bold sailors. I have sailed in both directions around the coasts up and down to Santander via Royan, Arcachon, St Jean de Luc and San Sebastian. I have crossed Biscay from Audierne once to Gijon and once to la Coruña. I have crossed once to Santander from Ile d'Yeu and twice from Santander to Ile d'Oléron. My age is a matter of perspective. My grandchildren think that I am very old! That is as may be, but I am far from bold! 

Return to Top


Return to Home Page


© Frank Singleton, December 2002